Определены критерии оценки достаточности доказательств. Ключевые слова: оценка доказательств, достаточность, следователь, полнота следствия, прокурор.


Чтобы посмотреть этот PDF файл с форматированием и разметкой, скачайте файл и откройте на своем компьютере.
!"#$%&%$& '()$*( -.,/,#%01 2&/(1 $3*,4$5&36$7 ,+0* 3,#4&1&%%,3*8 ;(.4236( �6(&240 +4(#( ?&*#&4*07 �(6-/8*&* +,#[email protected]&%$ �6#(/$$6(=$$ 2$3/,6(=$&7 A$B%$7 A,#.,4,2 C%3*$*-*( +,#[email protected]&%$ 6#(/$�$6(=$$ :6(2&1$ D/&23*#&%%,., 6,1$*&*( E,33$736,7 F&2&4(=$$ "#$%#&' (#&)*)#+ ,#&)- (#!*.*)/01&)" #2"-,/,-3 3*(*8& $33/&2-H*3 +4,"/&1 *&,4$$ +4(6*$6$ ,=&%6$ 2,3*(*,5%,3*$ 2,6('(*&/83*# :#*,4,1 4(331,*4&%0 4('/$5%0& *,56$ '4&%$ +,%*$& 2,3*(*,5%,3*$ 2,6('(*&/83*# !+4&2&/&%0 64$*&4$$ ,=&%6$ 2,3*(*,5%,3*$ 2,6('(*&/83*# !",'%(5&%0 +-*$ +4&,2,/&%$ 4('/$5%0I +,2I,2,# ,=&%6& 2,3*( *,5%,3*$ 2,6('(*&/83*# +4(#,+4$1&%$*&/8%,7 +4(6*$6& J/H5�& 3/,#( ,=&%6( 2,6('(*&/83*# 2,3*(*,5%,3*8 3/&2,#(*&/8 +,/%,*( 3/&23*#$ +4,6-4,4 !"##$%&'(")*% +,%#-.+$%)*/ +,%&#-"($0%- #'1'/ #$'2)3/ 4)'5'5,"))3/ +,'6%## (3+'$)%)*0 .5'$'()'5' .&'+,'*7('&#-(" 9&)'/ 5$"()3: ,"##$%&'(")*0 .5'$'()34 &%$"4 0($0%-#0 #'1*,")*% +,'(%,;" '6%);" &';"7"-%$#-( ;'-',34* +')*4"=-#0 $=13% #(%&%)*0 '#)'(% ;'-',3: #.& #$%&'("-%$ .#-")'($%))'4 �5'$'()' +,'6%##."$ )34 ;'&%;#'4 !'##*/#;'/ ?%&%,"6** .#-")"($*("%- )"$*8*% '-#.-#-(*% '1#-'0-%$#-( +'&$%2"@*: &';"73(")*= +,* +,'*7('&#-(% .5'$'()'4. -";2% '1#-'0-%$#-( *4%[email protected]*: 7)"8%)*% A"#- 88 .#-")"($*("%- ;"2&'% &';"7"-%$#-(' +'&$%2*- '6%);% -'8;* 7,%)*0 '-)'#*4'#-* &'+.#-*4'#-* &'#-'(%,)'#-* (#% #'1,"))3% &';"7"-%$#-(" #'(';.+)'#-* &'#-"-'8)'#-* ,"7,%D%)*0 &%$" 9&)";' ,"#;,3("%- &'#-"-'8)'#-* . F.+*)#;"0 #+,"(%&$*(' '-4%8"%- &'#-"-'8)'#- &"))3: (#%5&" +,%&4%-)" &'#-"-'8)" 8%5' '+,%&%$0%-#0 +,*4%)*-%$)' !"#$%&%$& '()$*( -.,/,#%01 2&/(1 $3*,4$5&36$7 ,+0* 3,#4&1&%%,3*8 '+,%&%$%))'4. ,%D%)*= *#:'&0 %5' 4%#-" (#%/ #*#-%4% ,%D%)*/ #-"&** ;'-','/ +,*)*4"%-#0 6%$* . [3, . 93]. &';"7"-%$#-( ,"7)'4. "(-','( +,*&%,2*("=-#0 +'7*6** &'#-"-'8)'#- &';"7"-%$#-( +,%*4 [email protected]%#-(%))' $'5*8%#;"0 '1,"1'-;" H";-*8%#;'/ *)H',4"6** #''-(%-#-(** 7";')"4* 43D$%)*0 [1, 85]. I,.5*% +')*4"=- &'#-"-'8)'#-= #'(';.+)'#- '-)'#*43: &'+.#-*43: &'#-'(%,)3: '1,"@"0 +,* ()*4")*% %&*)#-(' #('/#-( +'7('$0%- (3('& #+'#'1)'#-* .#-")"($*("- '1#-'0-%$#-(" &%$" [5, . 144]. E)"$*7 -'8%; 7,%)*0 .8%)3: J-'/ +,'1$%4% +'7('$0%- #&%$"- #'1*,"-%$)3/ (3('& -'4 8-' &'#-"-'8)'#- #('/#-(' &';"7"-%$#-( :"," ;-%,*[email protected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email protected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�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email protected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email protected]%% C"; +,%&(",*-%$)'4 #$%&#-(** -"; #.&%1)'5' 7"#%&")*0 #('% .8"#-*% ;,"2% '-,*6"$* .$*8"$* &'+,'D%))3% #(*&%-%$* 4%#-% +,'*#D%#-(*0 '1)",.2%)3 '-+%8"-;* +"$6%( ;'-',3% ;"; .#-")'(*$" J;#+%,-*7" +,*)"&$%2"- K.& +,*D%$ (3('&. +,*8"#-)'#-* +,%#-.+$%)*= $*D -'4 '#)'(")** 8-' (,%4 '13#;" &'4% '1)",.2%)3 )%;'-',3% (%@* 8*#$" +':*@%))3: #;$"&" 9&)";' ;";*4 '1,"7'4 (%@* +'+"$* .#-")'($%)' 13$' G4%#-% -%4 )%;'-',3% &"))3% *4%[email protected]*%#0 &%$% #(*&%-%$#-(.=- 8-' 4'5$' +,'*7'/-* ,%7.$-"-% .8"# -*0 '1'*: ;,"2% 8"#-)'#-* 13$ +,*0-%$%4 13$ 2%)"- #%#-,% +'#$%&)%5' +,*%72"$" 4"- +';"7"$" (%@%/ +,*(%7$" ')" !"##4'-,%( 4"-%,*"$3 &%$" ;"##"6*'))"0 *)#-")6*0 +,*D$" (3('&. )%'1:'&*4'#-* '-4%) '1)",.2%)*% (%@%/ &'4% &"("$' '#)'(")*0 7"+'&'7,*- +,*8"#-)'#-* #'(%,D%))'4. +,%#-.+$%)*= '&)";' '-#.-#-(** &,.5*: !"#$%&%$& '()$*( -.,/,#%01 2&/(1 $3*,4$5&36$7 ,+0* 3,#4&1&%%,3*8 13$' 0()' )%&'#-"-'8)34 +,*7)")*0 '()34* ;,"2% [6] �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email protected]%#-(*- 1%7 +,'(%&%)*0 &'#$%&#-(%))'/ +,'(%,;* G4%#-% .5'$'()3: ('74'2)' ,%D%)*/ +,'(%&%)** -%: *)3: #$%&#-(%))3: &%/#-(*/ '#)'(")** ,%7.$-"-'( '+%,"-*()' ,'73#;)'/ &%0-%$)'#-* M"+,*4%, +,*)0-*0 ,%D%)*0 +,'(%&%)** '+'7)")*0 '1(*)0%4'5' #(*&%-%$%4 .#$'(*0: *#;$=8"[email protected]*: %5' (*7."$)'% )"1$=&%)*% )%'1:'&*4" $*D *)H',4"6*0 +'&-(%, 2&"[email protected]"0 #[email protected]%#-('(")*% .5,'73 '+"#)'#-* '-)'D%)** &"))'5' #(*&%-%$0 %5' ,'&#-(%))*;'( 1$*7;*: !"#$%&%$& '()$*( -.,/,#%01 2&/(1 $3*,4$5&36$7 ,+0* 3,#4&1&%%,3*8 I$0 +,%&L0($%)*0 '1(*)%)*0 .5'$'()'4. &%$. &';"7"-%$#-(" 4'2)' #8*-"- &'#-"-'8)34* ')* +,*('&0- )%#'4)%))'4. (3('&. &';"7"))'#-* H"; -*8%#;*: '1,"[email protected]*: +,%&4%- &';"73(")*0 K.1L%;- &';"73(")*0 ,%D%)** #('%4. ().-,%))%4. .1%2&%)*= '+,%&%$0%- #'(';.+)'#- )%'1:'&*4" .#-")'($%)*0 *$* S-' '7)"8"%- +*D%- C'#-%);' 8-' #H',4.$*,'("- ;'$*8%#-(%))3/ ;,*-%,*/ +'7('[email protected]*/ *74%,*- )"&%2)'#- #&%$"))'5' (3('&" (*)'()'#-* ;');,%-)'5' #'(%,D%)** +,%#-.+$%)*0 .#-")'($%)** &,.5*: +,%&4%-" &';"73(")*0 -";2% *)3: '1#-'0-%$#-(": *4%[email protected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�#-")'(*- 7";')'&"-%$)'4 ;,*-%,** &'#-"-'8)'#-* ('74'2)' #*$. +%,%8*#$%))3: )"#-'[email protected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email protected])'#- 4%-'&3 C'#-%);' O%',%-*8%#;*% 7";')'&"-%$)3% +,"('+,*4%)*-%$)3% "#+%;-3 +')0-*0 .5'$'()' +,'6%##."$)3: &';"7"-%$#-( C,"#)'&", F.+*)#;"0 !%D%)*0 .5'$'()'4 #.&'+,'*7('&#-(% #'&%,2")*% H',43 !%D%-)*;'(" &';"7"-%$#-(%))'5' +,"(" ,'##*/#;'4 5,"2&")#;'4 #.&'+,'*7('&#-(% �$0)'(" B,%&4%- &';"73(")*0 &';"7"-%$#-(" .5'$'()'4 +,'6%##% !'##** �8%1)'% +'#'1*% .: ",:*( C*,'(#;'5' ,"/ '))'5' #.&" Q;"-%,*)1.,5"

Приложенные файлы

  • pdf 42712449
    Размер файла: 165 kB Загрузок: 0

Добавить комментарий