Определены критерии оценки достаточности доказательств. Ключевые слова: оценка доказательств, достаточность, следователь, полнота следствия, прокурор.


Чтобы посмотреть этот PDF файл с форматированием и разметкой, скачайте его и откройте на своем компьютере.
!"#$%&%$&
'()$*(
-.,/,#%01
2&/(1
$3*,4$5&36$7
,+0*
3,#4&1&%%,3*8
;(.4236(
�6(&240
+4(#(
?&*#&4*07
�(6-/8*&*
+,#[email protected]&%$
�6#(/$$6(=$$
2$3/,6(=$&7
A$B%$7
A,#.,4,2
C%3*$*-*(
+,#[email protected]&%$
6#(/$�$6(=$$
:6(2&1$
D/&23*#&%%,.,
6,1$*&*(
E,33$736,7
F&2&4(=$$
"#$%#&'
(#&)*)#+
,#&)-
(#!*.*)/01&)"
#2"-,/,-3
3*(*8&
$33/&2-H*3
+4,"/&1
*&,4$$
+4(6*$6$
,=&%6$
2,3*(*,5%,3*$
2,6('(*&/83*#
:#*,4,1
4(331,*4&%0
4('/$5%0&
*,56$
'4&%$
+,%*$&
2,3*(*,5%,3*$
2,6('(*&/83*#
!+4&2&/&%0
64$*&4$$
,=&%6$
2,3*(*,5%,3*$
2,6('(*&/83*#
!",'%(5&%0
+-*$
+4&,2,/&%$
4('/$5%0I
+,2I,2,#
,=&%6&
2,3*(
*,5%,3*$
2,6('(*&/83*#
+4(#,+4$1&%$*&/8%,7
+4(6*$6&
J/H5�&
3/,#(
,=&%6(
2,6('(*&/83*#
2,3*(*,5%,3*8
3/&2,#(*&/8
+,/%,*(
3/&23*#$
+4,6-4,4
!"##$%&'(")*%
+,%#-.+$%)*/
+,%&#-"($0%-
#'1'/
#$'2)3/
4)'5'5,"))3/
+,'6%##
(3+'$)%)*0
.5'$'()'5'
.&'+,'*7('&#-("
9&)'/
5$"()3:
,"##$%&'(")*0
.5'$'()34
&%$"4
0($0%-#0
#'1*,")*%
+,'(%,;"
'6%);"
&';"7"-%$#-(
;'-',34*
+')*4"=-#0
$=13%
#(%&%)*0
'#)'(%
;'-',3:
#.&
#$%&'("-%$
.#-")'($%))'4
�5'$'()'
+,'6%##."$
)34
;'&%;#'4
!'##*/#;'/
?%&%,"6**
.#-")"($*("%-
)"$*8*%
'-#.-#-(*%
'1#-'0-%$#-(
+'&$%2"@*:
&';"73(")*=
+,*
+,'*7('&#-(%
.5'$'()'4.
-";2%
'1#-'0-%$#-(
*4%[email protected]*:
7)"8%)*%
A"#-
88
.#-")"($*("%-
;"2&'%
&';"7"-%$#-('
+'&$%2*-
'6%);%
-'8;*
7,%)*0
'-)'#*4'#-*
&'+.#-*4'#-*
&'#-'(%,)'#-*
(#%
#'1,"))3%
&';"7"-%$#-("
#'(';.+)'#-*
&'#-"-'8)'#-*
,"7,%D%)*0
&%$"
9&)";'
,"#;,3("%-
&'#-"-'8)'#-*
.
F.+*)#;"0
#+,"(%&$*('
'-4%8"%-
&'#-"-'8)'#-
&"))3:
(#%5&"
+,%&4%-)"
&'#-"-'8)"
8%5'
'+,%&%$0%-#0
+,*4%)*-%$)'
!"#$%&%$&
'()$*(
-.,/,#%01
2&/(1
$3*,4$5&36$7
,+0*
3,#4&1&%%,3*8
'+,%&%$%))'4.
,%D%)*=
*#:'&0
%5'
4%#-"
(#%/
#*#-%4%
,%D%)*/
#-"&**
;'-','/
+,*)*4"%-#0
6%$*
. [3,
. 93].
&';"7"-%$#-(
,"7)'4.
"(-','(
+,*&%,2*("=-#0
+'7*6**
&'#-"-'8)'#-
&';"7"-%$#-(
+,%*4
[email protected]%#-(%))'
$'5*8%#;"0
'1,"1'-;"
H";-*8%#;'/
*)H',4"6**
#''-(%-#-(**
7";')"4*
43D$%)*0
[1,
85].
I,.5*%
+')*4"=-
&'#-"-'8)'#-=
#'(';.+)'#-
'-)'#*43:
&'+.#-*43:
&'#-'(%,)3:
'1,"@"0
+,*
()*4")*%
%&*)#-('
#('/#-(
+'7('$0%-
(3('&
#+'#'1)'#-*
.#-")"($*("-
'1#-'0-%$#-("
&%$"
[5,
. 144].
E)"$*7
-'8%;
7,%)*0
.8%)3:
J-'/
+,'1$%4%
+'7('$0%-
#&%$"-
#'1*,"-%$)3/
(3('&
-'4
8-'
&'#-"-'8)'#-
#('/#-('
&';"7"-%$#-(
:","
;-%,*[email protected]%%
'&)'
'-&%$)'
(70-'%
&';"7"-%$#-('
#'(';.+)'#-
B,*8%4
#'(';.+)'#-
(#%5&"
#('%/
'#)'(%
1.&%-
(%$*8*)'/
;"8%#-(%))'/
;'$*8%#-(%))'/
B'#;'$;.
#'(';.+)'#-
(#%5&"
+','2&%)*%
'&)'5'
&';"7"-%$#-("
&,.5*4
K''-(%-#-(%))'
6%)*-
&'#-"-'8)'#-
&';"7"-%$#-(
'7)"8"%-
#&%$"-
(3('&
'1#-'0-%$#-('
+'&$%2"@%%
.#-")'($%)*=
+,'6%##%
&';"73(")*0
.5'$'()'4.
&%$.
.#-")"($*("%-#0
'+,'(%,5"%-#0
#'(';.+)'#-=
'-)'#*43:
&'+.#-*43:
&'#-'(%,)3:
';"7"-%$#-(
;'-',3%
*4%=-#0
4"-%,*"$":
&%$"
)":'&0-#0
4%2&.
$'5*8%#;'/
(7"*4'#(07*
(7"*4'7"(*#*4'#-*
#(07*
7";')
*4%))'
'1L%4%
&';"7"-%$#-("
4'2)'
#8*-"-
&'#-"-'8)34*
'6%);"
'#-"-'8)'#-*
#$%&#-(%))'/
+,";-*;%
7)"8*-%$)'
7"-,.&)%)"
G'7)*;"%-
7";')'4%,)3/
;";
'6%)*("%-#0
&'#-"-'8)'#-
&';"7"-%$#-(
M"+,*4%,
%#$*
.1*/#-('
#'(%,D%)'
H.-1'$)'4
#-"&*')%
(,%40
+,'(%&%)*0
4"-8"
+';"7")*0
#;'$;*:
7,*-%$%/
1'$%[email protected]*;'(
'8%(*&6%(
#'13-*0
1.&%-
&'#-"-'8)'
!"#$%&%$&
'()$*(
-.,/,#%01
2&/(1
$3*,4$5&36$7
,+0*
3,#4&1&%%,3*8
,%D%)*%
&';"7"-%$#-(
7"(*#*-
7)")*/
H";-*8%#;*:
'1#-'0-%$#-(":
&%$"
#$%&#-(%))'/
#*-."6**
+'J-'4.
'6%);"
&'#-"-'8)'#-*
*)H',4"6**
+,%&#-"($%))'
(*&%
&';"7"-%$#-(
(",*"-*()"
#*-."-*()"0
&,.5'/
#-',')3
'6%);"
#'(';.+)'#-*
&';"7"-%$#-(
&'#-"-'8)'/
'+,%&%$%)*%
'1L%4"
)%'1:'&*4'/
'1'#)'("))'5'
+,'6%##."$)'5'
,%D%)*0
*)H',4"6**
(#%5&"
*4%%-
8%,-3
#.1L%;-*()'#-*
;');,%-)34
+,"('+,*4%)*-%$%4
N#:'&0
+,*)6*+"
#('1'&3
'6%);*
&';"7"-%$#-(
;"2&'4
;');,%-)'4
#$.8"%
&%$"%-#0
*#;$=8*-%$)'
'#)'(")**
().-,%))%5'
.1%2&%)*0
+,"('+,*4%)*-%$0
('7)*;"=-
#*-."6**
'6%);"
&'#-"-'8)'#-*
&"))"0
#$%&'("-%$%4
#'(+"&"%-
'6%);'/
&'#-"-'8)'#-*
&"))'/
+,';.,','4
#.&%/
�5'$'()'
+,'6%##."$)34
#$%&#-(*%4
)%#'(+"&%)*0
'6%)';
&'#-"-'8)'#-*
+,%&.#4'-,%))"0
221
('74'2)'#-
('7(,"-*-
&%$'
#$%&'("-%$=
+,'*7('&#-("
&'+'$)*-%$)'5'
#$%&#-(*0
*74%)%)*0
'1L%4"
'1(*)%)*0
.
.1
. 221
).
9&)";'
H";-
('7(,"@%)*0
(#%5&"
0($0%-#0
#$%&#-(*%4
'D*
+,*
'6%);%
&'#-"-'8)'#-*
)%;'-',3:
*4%%-
4%#-'
+,'0($%)*%
'1L%;-*()'/
7";')'4%,)'#-*
*4%))'
)%#'(+"&%)*%
.#4'-,%)*0
#$%&'("-%$0
+,';.,',"
#*$.
,"7$*8)'5'
.5'$'()'
+,'6%##."$)'5'
#-"-.#"
#.1L%;-*()'5'
:",";
'6%)';
&'#-"-'8)'#-*
*)H',4"6**
+,%&#-"($%))'/
#'(';.+)'#-=
&';"7"-%$#-(
O";
)"+,*4%,
&'+'$)*-%$)'%
,"##$%&'(")*%
13$'
('7(,"@%)'
&%$'
28126
'1(*)%)*=
. 2
. 291
+'#-")'($%)**
('7(,"@%)**
.5'$'()'5'
&%$"
)%'1:'&*4'#-
J;#+%,-)'5'
*##$%&'(")*0
".&*'7"+*#*
+,'*7('&*(D%/#0
4'4%)-
#'(%,D%)*0
+,%#-.+$%)*0
,"##$%&'(")*0
&"))"0
7"+*#
13$"
!"#$%&%$&
'()$*(
-.,/,#%01
2&/(1
$3*,4$5&36$7
,+0*
3,#4&1&%%,3*8
+,'#$.D")"
'#4'-,%)"
+,*'[email protected]%)"
;"8%#-(%
(%@%#-(%))'5'
*##$%&'(")"
M"+,
"($00
+,';.,',.
&%$'
&$0
.-(%,2&%)*0
'1(*)*-%$)'5'
7";$=8%)*0
#$%&'("-%$
+'$"5"$
+,'(%&%)**
J;#+%,-*73
)%-
)%'1:'&*4'#-*
'1(*)0%4'5'
+,%#-.+$%)**
&';"7")"
'1L%4%
+'&-(%,2&"%-#0
#'(';.+)'#-=
*)3:
&';"7"-%$#-(
M%,%&;'
'&).
#'(';.+)'#-
&';"7"-%$#-(
'&)"
#.&%1)"0
*)#-")6*0
+,*7)"%-
&'#-"-'8)'/
&,.5"0
)%-
)"+,*4%,
#$.8*$'#
.5'$'()'4.
&%$.
'-)'D%)**
B,*5'(','4
C*,'(#;'5'
,"/'))'5'
#.&"
Q;"-%,*)1.,5"
13$*
'#.2&%)3
-'(",'(
#;$"&"
G*)'()'#-
13$"
.#-")'($%)"
1%##+',)'
+,*5'(',
'12"$'("$*
#('*:
;"##"6*'))3:
2"$'1":
#$%[email protected]%%
C";
+,%&(",*-%$)'4
#$%&#-(**
-";
#.&%1)'5'
7"#%&")*0
#('%
.8"#-*%
;,"2%
'-,*6"$*
.$*8"$*
&'+,'D%))3%
#(*&%-%$*
4%#-%
+,'*#D%#-(*0
'1)",.2%)3
'-+%8"-;*
+"$6%(
;'-',3%
;";
.#-")'(*$"
J;#+%,-*7"
+,*)"&$%2"-
K.&
+,*D%$
(3('&.
+,*8"#-)'#-*
+,%#-.+$%)*=
$*D
-'4
'#)'(")**
8-'
(,%4
'13#;"
&'4%
'1)",.2%)3
)%;'-',3%
(%@*
8*#$"
+':*@%))3:
#;$"&"
9&)";'
;";*4
'1,"7'4
(%@*
+'+"$*
.#-")'($%)'
13$'
G4%#-%
-%4
)%;'-',3%
&"))3%
*4%[email protected]*%#0
&%$%
#(*&%-%$#-(.=-
8-'
4'5$'
+,'*7'/-*
,%7.$-"-%
.8"#
-*0
'1'*:
;,"2%
8"#-)'#-*
13$
+,*0-%$%4
13$
2%)"-
#%#-,%
+'#$%&)%5'
+,*%72"$"
4"-
+';"7"$"
(%@%/
+,*(%7$"
')"
!"##4'-,%(
4"-%,*"$3
&%$"
;"##"6*'))"0
*)#-")6*0
+,*D$"
(3('&.
)%'1:'&*4'#-*
'-4%)
'1)",.2%)*%
(%@%/
&'4%
&"("$'
'#)'(")*0
7"+'&'7,*-
+,*8"#-)'#-*
#'(%,D%))'4.
+,%#-.+$%)*=
'&)";'
'-#.-#-(**
&,.5*:
!"#$%&%$&
'()$*(
-.,/,#%01
2&/(1
$3*,4$5&36$7
,+0*
3,#4&1&%%,3*8
13$'
0()'
)%&'#-"-'8)34
+,*7)")*0
'()34*
;,"2%
[6]
�8%)3%
#:'&0-#0
4)%)**
8-'
;"2&'4.
&%$.
&'#-"-'8)'#-
'6%)*("%-#0
*)&*(*&."$)'
)%('74'2)'
7",")%%
13$'
'&)'7)"8)3/
+,*%4$%43/
[4,
. 152].
7"(*#*4'#-*
"%4'5'
#$%&'("-%$%4
,%D%)*0
#-"&**
,"##$%&'(")*0
&%$"
+,*)*4"%-#0
+,'6%##."$)3/
7";')
,"7$*8"%-
#-%+%)
&'#-"-'8)'#-*
&';"7"-%$#-(
M"*1'$%%
0,;'
+,'0($0%-#0
#,"()%)**
&'#-"-'8)'#-*
&';"7"-%$#-(
&$0
+,*)0-*0
,%D%)*/
('71.2&%)**
&%$"
+,*($%8%)**
'1(*)0%4'5'
M"+,*4%,
&'#-"-'8)'
&$0
('71.2&%)*0
.5'$'()'5'
&%$"
&'$2)'#-)'4
+,%#-.+$%)**
#'-,.&)*;"
9GI
'&)*:
9!I
M%#4'-,0
#''-(%-#-(**
. 11
?%&%,"$)'5'
7";')"
12
"(5.#-"
1995
. N 144
'+%,"-*()'
,'73#;)'/
&%0-%$)'#-*
,%7.$-"-3
'+%,"-*()'
,'73#;)'/
&%0-%
$)'#-*
4'5.-
#$.2*-
'#)'(")*%4
('71.2&%)*0
&%$"
(3)%#%)*0
+'#-")'($%)*0
('71.2&%)**
&%$"
#$%&'("-%$%4
)%&'#-"-'8)'
&"))'/
;"-%5',**
.5'$'()3:
9!I
&'$2)3
+'&$%2"-
'107"-%$)'/
+,'(%,;%
%);%
+,%&4%-
7";'))'#-*
+'$.8%)*0
+,%&#-"($%)*0
'-)'#*4'#-*
&'#-'(%,)'#-*
8"@%
(#%5'
)%('74'2)'
'#[email protected]%#-(*-
1%7
+,'(%&%)*0
&'#$%&#-(%))'/
+,'(%,;*
G4%#-%
.5'$'()3:
('74'2)'
,%D%)*/
+,'(%&%)**
-%:
*)3:
#$%&#-(%))3:
&%/#-(*/
'#)'(")**
,%7.$-"-'(
'+%,"-*()'
,'73#;)'/
&%0-%$)'#-*
M"+,*4%,
+,*)0-*0
,%D%)*0
+,'(%&%)**
'+'7)")*0
'1(*)0%4'5'
#(*&%-%$%4
.#$'(*0:
*#;$=8"[email protected]*:
%5'
(*7."$)'%
)"1$=&%)*%
)%'1:'&*4"
$*D
*)H',4"6*0
+'&-(%,
2&"[email protected]"0
#[email protected]%#-('(")*%
.5,'73
'+"#)'#-*
'-)'D%)**
&"))'5'
#(*&%-%$0
%5'
,'&#-(%))*;'(
1$*7;*:
!"#$%&%$&
'()$*(
-.,/,#%01
2&/(1
$3*,4$5&36$7
,+0*
3,#4&1&%%,3*8
I$0
+,%&L0($%)*0
'1(*)%)*0
.5'$'()'4.
&%$.
&';"7"-%$#-("
4'2)'
#8*-"-
&'#-"-'8)34*
')*
+,*('&0-
)%#'4)%))'4.
(3('&.
&';"7"))'#-*
H";
-*8%#;*:
'1,"[email protected]*:
+,%&4%-
&';"73(")*0
K.1L%;-
&';"73(")*0
,%D%)**
#('%4.
().-,%))%4.
.1%2&%)*=
'+,%&%$0%-
#'(';.+)'#-
)%'1:'&*4"
.#-")'($%)*0
*$*
S-'
'7)"8"%-
+*D%-
C'#-%);'
8-'
#H',4.$*,'("-
;'$*8%#-(%))3/
;,*-%,*/
+'7('[email protected]*/
*74%,*-
)"&%2)'#-
#&%$"))'5'
(3('&"
(*)'()'#-*
;');,%-)'5'
#'(%,D%)**
+,%#-.+$%)*0
.#-")'($%)**
&,.5*:
+,%&4%-"
&';"73(")*0
-";2%
*)3:
'1#-'0-%$#-(":
*4%[email protected]*:
7)"8%)*%
&$0
.5'$'()'5'
&%$"
H";-*8%#;*
+,%&#-"($0%-#0
('74'2)34
[2,
. 144].
98%(*&)'
J-'4
'-)'D%)**
.;"7"))34
6%$04
#$.2*-
+')0-*%
+,%&%$'(
&';"73(")*0
;'-','%
+,*7(")'
'&)'/
#-',')3
'1%#+%8*-
&'#-"-'8)'#-
&'+.#-*-
1%74%,)'5'
)%'1'#)'("))'5'
,"#D*,%)*0
J-*:
+,%&%$'(
)",.D%)*0
,"7.4)'#-*
#,';'(
+,%&(",*-%$)'5'
#$%&#-(*0
O";*4
&'#-"-'8)'#-
'6%)'8)3/
;,*-%,*/
&';"7"-%$#-(%))'/
*)H',4"6**
*#+'$7.%43
.5'$'()'4
+,'6%##%
'6%);*
&';"7"-%$#-(
*4%%-
8%,-3
)%'+,%&%$%))'#-*
;'-',"0
'1,"7.%-#0
'1L%;-*()34*
#*-."6*'))34*
H";-',"4*
#.1L%;-*()34
H";-','4
(3,"2%))34
.#4'-,%)**
+,"('+,*4%)*-%$0
#$%&'("-%$0
&'7)"("-%$0
#.&"
#('=
'8%,%&
)%'+,%
&%$%))'#-
;,*-%,*0
&'#-"-'8)'#-*
)%'+,%&%$%))'#-
;,*-%,*0
+'$)'-3
+,'(%&%))'5'
#$%&#-(*0
8-'
&%$"%-
('74'2)34
+",'/
1%7'#)'("-%$)'
('7(,"@"-
.5'$'()3%
&%$"
+',0&;%
+,%&.#4'-,%))'4
221
4'-*(*,'(;'/
&$0
&'+'$)*
-%$)'5'
,"##$%&'(")*0
*7.8%)*0
4"-%,*"$'(
&%$"
(30($%)3
)%+'$)'-"
'&)'#-','))'#-
,"##$%&'(")*0
�#-")'(*-
7";')'&"-%$)'4
;,*-%,**
&'#-"-'8)'#-*
('74'2)'
#*$.
+%,%8*#$%))3:
)"#-'[email protected]%/
#-"-%
!"#$%&%$&
'()$*(
-.,/,#%01
2&/(1
$3*,4$5&36$7
,+0*
3,#4&1&%%,3*8
6%$=
4";#*4"$)'5'
*#;$=8%)*0
)%'1'#)'("))'
('7(,"@%))3:
.5'$'()3:
+,'*7('&#-("
&'+'$)*-%$)'5'
#$%&#-(*0
4'-*(*,'(;'/
)%+'$)'-"
+,%&$"5"%4
1'$%%
-'8)'
'+,%&%$*-
'#)'(")*0
+,'(%&%)*0
&'+'$)*-%$)'5'
#$%&#-(*0
O";2%
+'$"5"%4
6%$%#''1,"7
)34
7";,%+*-
+,'6%##."$)'4
7";')'&"-%$#-(%
+'$'2%)*%
#'5$"#)'
;'-','4.
+,';.,',
#-"&**
+,%&(",*-%$)'5'
#$%&#-(*0
)"+,*4%,
*7.8%)**
+'#-")'($%)*0
+,*($%8%)**
;"8%#-(%
'1(*)0%4'5'
#'(4%#-)'5'
,.;'('&#-('4
#$%&'("-%$04*
#$%&#
-(%))'5'
',5")"
'+,%&%$%)**
&'#-"-'8)'#-*
+,'(%&%))'5'
#$%&#-(*0
6%$0:
(3,"1'-;*
%&*)'5'
;,*-%,*0
&'#-"-'8)'#-*
&';"7"-%$#-(
'1(*)%)*0
;"2&'4.
;');,%-)'4.
.5'$'()'4.
24564789:;4
T%$;*)
K'1*,")*%
*##$%&'(")*%
'6%);"
&';"7"-%$#-(
[email protected])'#-
4%-'&3
C'#-%);'
O%',%-*8%#;*%
7";')'&"-%$)3%
+,"('+,*4%)*-%$)3%
"#+%;-3
+')0-*0
.5'$'()'
+,'6%##."$)3:
&';"7"-%$#-(
C,"#)'&",
F.+*)#;"0
!%D%)*0
.5'$'()'4
#.&'+,'*7('&#-(%
#'&%,2")*%
H',43
!%D%-)*;'("
&';"7"-%$#-(%))'5'
+,"("
,'##*/#;'4
5,"2&")#;'4
#.&'+,'*7('&#-(%
�$0)'("
B,%&4%-
&';"73(")*0
&';"7"-%$#-("
.5'$'()'4
+,'6%##%
!'##**
�8%1)'%
+'#'1*%
.:
",:*(
C*,'(#;'5'
,"/
'))'5'
#.&"
Q;"-%,*)1.,5"

Приложенные файлы

  • pdf 42712449
    Размер файла: 165 kB Загрузок: 0

Добавить комментарий